All You Need to Know About Replacing Vinyl Siding With Wood

Learn whether it’s possible and what you shall take into account before doing it
Updated on:

Thinking about swapping out that old vinyl siding for the classic look of wood? You're not alone! It's a popular upgrade that can seriously boost your home's curb appeal. While vinyl has its place, nothing quite matches the natural beauty and warmth of real wood.

This project is definitely a step up from basic DIY, but the results can be stunning. We'll walk you through why wood is making a comeback, what to expect when replacing vinyl, different styles and types to consider, the process involved, and the all important factors like cost and maintenance.

Let's dive in!

 

A charming house featuring wood siding for an elegant and natural look
Photo by Katie Wasserman on Unsplash

Why Choose Wood Siding Exterior?

So, what's the big deal with wood siding exterior anyway? Well, for starters, it just looks fantastic. Each plank has unique grain patterns and textures that add character and depth vinyl simply can't replicate. It gives your home a rich, premium feel that boosts curb appeal instantly.

 

Wood is also incredibly versatile. You can paint it any color imaginable, stain it to highlight the natural grain, or even let some types like cedar weather naturally to a beautiful silvery gray. It works well with almost any architectural style, from rustic cabins to sleek modern designs.

 

Beyond looks, wood siding exterior is a natural, renewable resource, which appeals to homeowners looking for more sustainable building materials. When properly maintained, it can last for decades, sometimes even longer than vinyl, especially in harsh climates where vinyl might crack or warp. 

While it requires more upkeep, many feel the aesthetic payoff and the satisfaction of using a traditional, natural material are well worth the extra effort involved in its care and preservation over the years.

Moving On From Vinyl Siding Ideas Exterior

Let's be real, while vinyl siding is often budget friendly and low maintenance initially, it has drawbacks that lead homeowners to look for alternatives. Many vinyl siding ideas exterior can end up looking a bit flat or artificial compared to natural materials.

Over time, vinyl can fade, especially darker colors exposed to intense sun. It can also become brittle in cold weather, making it susceptible to cracking from impacts (think hail or stray baseballs). Repairing damaged vinyl often means replacing entire panels, and finding an exact color match for older siding can be tricky.

Another factor is the environmental aspect. Vinyl is a plastic product derived from fossil fuels, and its manufacturing process isn't the greenest. While some vinyl siding ideas exterior might incorporate recycled content, it's generally less sustainable than wood.

Plus, dealing with issues like surface mildew, which requires regular maintenance can be annoying. For homeowners prioritizing natural aesthetics, durability against impacts in some climates, and sustainability, moving away from vinyl towards options like wood makes a lot of sense.

Exploring Different Siding Ideas Exterior

Okay, so you're leaning towards wood. Awesome! But "wood siding" isn't just one thing. There are tons of siding ideas exterior when it comes to wood types and styles.

Common wood species include

  1. pine (affordable, needs good finishing)
  2. cedar (naturally rot and insect resistant, smells great),
  3. redwood (durable, beautiful color, often pricier),
  4. and engineered wood (wood fibers bonded with resin, often pre primed, stable).

Each has its own look, cost, and maintenance needs.

Beyond the wood type, you've got style choices. Classic lap siding (overlapping horizontal boards) is timeless. Then there are popular options like board and batten siding (vertical boards with thin strips covering the seams) giving that farmhouse vibe, or shiplap (boards that interlock tightly) for a smooth, modern look.

Exploring these different siding ideas exterior helps you narrow down the perfect fit for your home's architecture and your personal taste before you commit to the project.For a comprehensive guide on exterior finishing techniques, refer to our detailed article

Vinyl Siding vs. Wood Siding: A Quick Comparison

Feature Vinyl Siding Wood Siding
Aesthetics Uniform, can look artificial Natural, unique grain, rich appearance
Cost (Initial) Lower Higher
Maintenance Low (occasional washing) Higher (painting/staining every 3-7 yrs)
Durability Can crack, fade, warp Can rot/warp if unmaintained, durable if kept
Installation Easier, faster More complex, requires skill
Environmental Plastic, less sustainable Natural, renewable resource
Repairability Often requires full panel replacement Can often repair/replace single boards
Versatility Limited colors/styles per product line Paint/stain any color, various styles

The Popularity of Board and Batten Siding

 

You've probably seen board and batten siding everywhere lately, especially on homes going for that modern farmhouse look. It's characterized by wide vertical boards joined by thin vertical strips called battens covering the seams.

This creates really appealing shadow lines and a distinct vertical emphasis that can make a house feel taller and more stately. It’s a classic style that’s been updated for modern tastes, offering a clean yet textured appearance that homeowners love.

 

While traditionally made from wood, you can now find board and batten siding options in fiber cement and even vinyl or metal, though wood remains a popular choice for authenticity.

Proper installation is key to performance and appearance; understanding wall structure basics is crucial before installing the boards and battens correctly to ensure they are weather resistant and look great for years to come. Its versatility allows it to be used as an accent or for the entire exterior.

Considering Vertical Siding Exterior

 

Going vertical is a definite style statement! Using vertical siding exterior applications, like board and batten or channel siding (where boards have a recessed channel at the join), breaks away from the traditional horizontal look.

 

This vertical orientation naturally draws the eye upward, which can make one story homes appear taller or add visual interest to specific architectural features like gables or entryways. It offers a clean, contemporary feel that works well on modern and transitional style homes.

 

Functionally, some argue that vertical siding exterior might shed water more effectively than horizontal lap siding, potentially reducing risks of moisture getting trapped.

 

Installation requires careful attention to detail, especially ensuring proper water management with flashing and potentially a rainscreen system behind the siding to allow for drainage and drying.

It’s a stylish alternative if you're looking for something different from the usual horizontal layout.

Achieving the Modern Farmhouse Exterior Look

The modern farmhouse exterior style is hugely popular, blending rustic charm with clean, contemporary lines. Wood siding is a key ingredient in nailing this aesthetic.

 

Think crisp white board and batten siding or simple horizontal lap siding, often contrasted with black window frames, metal roof accents (like on a porch or dormer), and simple, sturdy posts or columns. The goal is a look that's welcoming and timeless but updated for today’s sensibilities.

 

Color palettes for a modern farmhouse exterior usually lean towards neutrals like whites, creams, grays, and sometimes darker charcoal or navy tones. Natural wood elements, like cedar posts or a wooden front door, add warmth and texture against the painted siding.

 

It's about creating a balance between cozy traditional farmhouse elements and sleek modern design, and wood siding exterior provides the perfect canvas for achieving this sought after style.

Using Mixed Siding Exterior Materials

 

Why stick to just one material when you can create unique visual interest by using mixed siding exterior finishes? This trend involves combining different siding materials, textures, and sometimes orientations on a home's facade.

 

For instance, you might see a house with horizontal wood lap siding on the main body, accented with stone veneer around the base and board and batten siding in the gables. This approach adds depth, highlights architectural features, and creates a custom, high end look.

 

Successfully executing a mixed siding exterior design requires careful planning. You need to consider how the different materials will transition, ensuring proper flashing and water management at the seams.

 

Color coordination is also key to making the combination look intentional rather than haphazard. Sometimes this approach is even practical, maybe using durable stone near the ground level where finishing the foundation edge matters, with wood siding above.

Choosing Siding Colors For Houses Made of Wood

 

One of the great things about wood siding is the world of color it opens up! When selecting siding colors for houses with wood exteriors, you have two main paths: paint or stain. Paint offers opaque color and excellent protection but requires scraping and repainting down the line.

 

Stains can be semi transparent (showing wood grain) or solid; they tend to fade more gracefully than paint peels but might need reapplication sooner. Your choice affects both the look and the maintenance schedule.

 

Popular siding colors for houses featuring wood include timeless whites and creams, earthy greens and blues, warm grays, and even bold dark hues like charcoal or black for a modern statement. Natural wood tones achieved with clear or lightly tinted sealers are also classic. Don't forget coordinating trim and accent colors!

 

Proper surface preparation, similar to how you need good prep before painting drywall, is essential for a lasting finish on your wood siding exterior.

Key Steps in This House Siding Ideas Exterior Project

Tackling a siding replacement is a major undertaking, so understanding the basic steps involved in this kind of house siding ideas exterior project is crucial. First comes the tear off: carefully removing all the old vinyl siding and any existing trim or accessories. This reveals the sheathing (the layer beneath the siding, usually plywood or OSB) and the weather resistant barrier (WRB), often called house wrap. This step is critical for inspection.

 

Next is preparation. You'll need to inspect the sheathing for any rot or damage and make repairs. The WRB might need patching or complete replacement ensure it's properly installed and flashed around openings. Just like thorough site readiness is vital for new construction, good wall prep is key here.

 

Finally, the new wood siding exterior is installed, starting from the bottom up, ensuring level courses, proper nailing, and careful work around windows and doors. Then comes caulking, priming (if needed), and painting or staining. It's detailed work best left to pros unless you have significant experience.

Conclusion

Switching from vinyl to wood siding exterior is a significant upgrade that offers timeless beauty and natural appeal. While it demands a higher initial investment and more diligent maintenance compared to vinyl, the aesthetic rewards and potential increase in home value can be substantial. From classic lap siding to trendy board and batten siding, wood offers versatility to match nearly any style, including the ever popular modern farmhouse exterior. By understanding the process, costs, and upkeep involved, you can make an informed decision and enjoy the warmth and character that only real wood can bring to your home's facade.

 

Links on this topic to authoritative sources:
  1. Vinyl Siding : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vinyl_siding
  2. Siding (construction) : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siding_(construction)
  3. Engineered wood : https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Engineered_wood

Facts

These remarkable facts showcase the unique history and characteristics of wood and vinyl siding. Both have their merits, but the choice ultimately depends on homeowners' specific needs and aesthetic preferences.

  1. Historical Context: Vinyl siding came into the construction scene in the late 1950s as a replacement for aluminum siding. However, wood siding predates vinyl by centuries, with examples dating back to the 17th century in the United States alone.
  2. Durability Comparison: Though vinyl siding can last up to 60 years with proper care, it's hard to beat the lifespan of wood. Some historical buildings with wood siding are still standing after 200 years!
  3. Environmental Impact: Wood siding is considered more environmentally friendly as it's biodegradable. However, the production process for vinyl siding releases fewer greenhouse gases compared to wood siding.
  4. The Transformation: Switching from vinyl to wood siding isn't a small task. It's a significant renovation project that usually involves removing the existing vinyl siding, repairing any damaged areas underneath, and then installing the wood siding.
  5. Record-breaking Renovation: The largest recorded residential project replacing vinyl siding with wood took place in 2002 in California. The colossal 15,000 square-foot home required over 15,000 linear feet of wood siding!
  6. Cost Factor: While vinyl siding is generally cheaper, a 2019 report by Remodeling Magazine stated that homeowners who replaced vinyl siding with wood recouped an average of 77.6% of the cost at resale, higher than the average for vinyl.
  7. Design Versatility: Wood siding provides more design options, as it can be painted or stained in any color, whereas vinyl siding color can fade over time and options can be limited by manufacturers.

History

Long before the emergence of modern materials, the story of home construction was defined by one material above all others - wood. It's hard to pinpoint the exact moment wood siding was introduced, as its use is as ancient as the concept of shelter itself. But, its legacy is etched into the buildings that have stood the test of time, offering a glimpse into the lives of people across millennia.

In the prehistoric era, our ancestors sought shelter in the natural world around them, using readily available materials to protect themselves from the elements. Wood, abundant and versatile, quickly became the go-to resource for creating robust and comfortable dwellings.

With the advent of early civilization, humans began to refine their construction techniques. In regions blessed with ample forests, like Northern Europe and parts of Asia, wood became the primary construction material. It was during this time that the practice of creating wooden sidings, designed to protect homes from harsh weather and improve their aesthetic appeal, began to evolve.

By the time the Middle Ages rolled around, wood siding had become an art. Builders would carefully carve and finish each piece, creating beautiful patterns and designs. Homes weren't just places to live anymore - they were canvases for self-expression, and wood siding was a crucial part of that narrative.

As settlers began to colonize the New World, they carried the tradition of wood siding with them. Using the rich timber resources of North America, they built homes, barns, and public buildings adorned with wood siding, laying the foundations of towns and cities that would flourish in the centuries to come.

But the introduction of wood siding wasn't without its challenges. It required regular maintenance to protect against weathering and pests. Over time, innovations like paint and later, treatments to enhance its durability, helped to prolong the life of wood siding.

In the modern era, despite competition from materials like vinyl and metal, wood siding remains popular. It offers a timeless charm that's hard to replicate, standing as a testament to the ingenuity of our ancestors who turned a raw, natural resource into a building staple.

Expert Advice

  1. Assess Your Current Siding: Begin by thoroughly inspecting your existing vinyl siding for damage, rot, or insect infestations. This will help you anticipate any additional repair work that might be needed during the replacement process.
  2. Choosing Your Wood: The type of wood you choose will greatly influence the appearance and durability of your siding. Cedar and redwood are popular choices due to their natural resistance to rot and insects.
  3. Hiring a Professional: While DIY can be tempting, replacing siding is a significant undertaking that requires expertise. Professionals will ensure proper installation, which is key to longevity.
  4. Maintenance is Key: Remember that wood siding requires more upkeep than vinyl. To maintain its beauty, it'll need to be painted or stained every few years.
  5. Prepare for the Cost: Wood siding is generally more expensive than vinyl, both in terms of material and installation costs. Ensure you budget accordingly to avoid unwanted financial surprises.
  6. Energy Efficiency Consideration: Wood has natural insulating properties. This could potentially lower your energy bills, adding another reason to make the switch.
  7. Embrace the Imperfections: One of the charms of wood siding is its natural imperfections. These quirks will give your home a unique, rustic appeal.
  8. Check Local Regulations: Some areas have regulations concerning the type of siding you can use. Ensure you check with local authorities before starting your project.
  9. By paying attention to these subtleties and tips, you can ensure a successful transformation from vinyl to wood siding, bringing warmth and a touch of nature to your home. Always remember, the time and effort invested in this transition are well worth the enduring appeal of wood siding.

 

Next time you take a stroll around your neighborhood and admire houses with wood siding, remember, it's not an impossible dream. With careful planning and professional help, you can bring that same charm to your own home. Just take the first step. 

Frequently Asked Questions

How Much Does Replacing Wood Siding Cost?

You should expect to pay from $200 to $300 or more per damaged panel.

How Often Should You Wash Wooden Siding?

Ideally, it should be washed once a year or once every one to two years.

Is It Safe To Pressure Wash Wood Siding?

While it's possible to pressure wash wood siding, you can also force water up and under the exterior surface if your water pressure is set too high. If water gets under the siding, it can damage insulation and electrical wiring!
Why Would Someone Consider Replacing Vinyl Siding With Wood?

People may choose to replace vinyl siding with wood for improved aesthetics, increased durability, or to maintain a more traditional appearance.

What Vinyl Siding Looks Most Like Wood
  1. Insulated vinyl siding: This type of siding offers a realistic wood-like appearance while providing enhanced energy efficiency and noise reduction.
  2. Cedar shake vinyl siding: Mimicking the look of natural cedar shakes, this siding option offers a rustic, charming appearance similar to real wood.
  3. Wood-grain embossed vinyl siding: Featuring a textured wood grain pattern, this siding replicates the look and feel of natural wood without the maintenance.
  4. Dutch lap vinyl siding: With its distinctive shadow lines and beveled edges, Dutch lap siding offers a traditional, wood-like appearance.
  5. Board and batten vinyl siding: Designed to replicate the look of vertical wood planks, this siding style adds a classic, timeless aesthetic to any home.
  6. Vinyl log siding: For those seeking a log cabin look, vinyl log siding accurately imitates the appearance of authentic wooden logs.
  7. Premium vinyl siding brands: Certain brands, such as CertainTeed and James Hardie, offer high-quality vinyl siding options that closely resemble real wood.
Publication date:

Comments

Russell Witting:
Hey guys! Do you know how I could remove stubborn stains from my wood siding? I though of bleach. Will that work?
Ike Abbott:
Hello! While bleach might seem to be a good mold and mildew deterrent, chlorine bleach can damage your wood siding. This is why you should consider a non-chlorine bleach, I suppose, like oxygen bleach, which is also more environmentally friendly.
Leave your comment